Tim's FIrst Appearance
Entry #9 is Tim's first appearance, making an appearance as a character talking to Sarah. It's apparent that he's playing a role in the movie, but it's never specified (not that it matters to the story of Marble Hornets). He gets upset and angry with Alex for berating himself, Sarah, and Seth.
In Entry #15, Tim makes his next appearance talking with Jay about potentially restarting the Marble Hornets movie, and Jay tells him it is simply a script reading, but really he's there to ask Tim info about Alex. Tim admits he knew Alex through Brian, That Alex didn't start off as a jerk when the production started, and stuff involving Alex finding dead animals in his yard, but knows nothing of what's become of Alex or Brian since the filming.
Tim's Third Appearance.
Entry #17 is flashback tape of filming for Marble Hornets, where Alex and Jay are filming Tim reading his lines for a random scene. The Operator appears to be standing in the window, but none of them notice.
Tim's Fourth Appearance.
In Entry #18, Masky makes his appearance, tackling Jay violently when Jay notices him sitting on the couch in another room, and falls to the ground having what viewers have deduced is some form of seizure. When Jay goes to take his mask off, he is attacked again, and wakes up hours later in his car (which is off the road) and without his pocket knife. At this point in the entries, Tim and Masky are separate entities.
Tim's Fifth Appearance.
Entry #19 has Jay looking over security footage of his room when he slept the night prior. He notices nothing for a while, then suddenly Masky shows up in his room, moving about his room for no explainable reason before vanishing. Jay also vanishes, but Jay notes he woke up in his bed the following day, meaning at some point he went back to bed. Whether The Operator took him, or Masky did is not yet stated.
In Entry #19.5, Jay does a video log of all the items he obtained from the house. He notes the bottle of pills is empty, and the bullet casing is gone, both assumed Masky took them. The pills may have belonged to Tim, as Entry #20 has Tim taking some odd pills and giving off odd distortion when he shows up in front of the camera, not to mention the camera quits for a moment just as Tim shows up to the house, the same way The Operator does when he gets near a camera.
Entry #23 shows Jay going back to Brian's house. During this, Masky runs about the house as Jay gives chase. Unlike last time, Masky never attacks Jay. At one point Masky hangs up his mask, although we don't see him without it, and Jay runs into The Operator.
Tim's Eighth Appearance.
Entry #33 is the next time Masky shows up. When Jay goes next door to get Jessica, she's gone. Without knowing where she is, he finds a safe combo and goes back to his room to open the safe, where Masky attacks him. Jay manages to fend off Masky and run with the tapes and his duffle bag, where Masky appears to have a limp (although this is debated). He gets away.
Entry #35 has Jay checking the dilapidated house for the second time. Although the previous entry had nothing
Tim's Ninth Appearance.
there, this time Masky is waiting in the building with a knife, however Alex shows up, foiling Masky's attack, and umasking him, revealing him to be Tim. Although Alex demans the knife, Jay refuses to do so, and instead Alex appears to smash Tim with a concrete block. The footage cuts to Jay driving. In Entry #36, it reveals that Alex only smashed his leg, to the disbelief of Jay, and Alex said he wanted to do worse. Since the audio distorts, it's hard to tell if they talk further about Tim.
Since Alex knew where Tim was, it can be assumed that he was actually hunting Tim down and intended to kill him, and that could mean that Tim was planning to kill Alex and not Jay, which is why he showed up the second time Jay went there when Alex conveniently did as well. It is also assumed that Tim had taken the knife from Jay way back in the plans to use it on Alex.
Tim's tenth appearance.
Entry #45 has Alex attempt to chase down and attack Hoody and Masky, but he falters and Masky almost hits him with a rock, before the duo run from an unseen entity. Alex then screams into the woods that if he sees them again they're dead.
Entry #50 is the next time Masky shows up, and has Jay chase him to the pipe in Rosswood Park after the footage of Jay talking with Alex. Jay eventually loses him, and doesn't seem to notice any reason for him following there.
Tim's twelfth appearance.
Entry #52 has Masky save both Jessica and Jay from Alex, who plans to shoot both of them in the woods. While Masky struggles with Alex, the other two run and hear a gunshot in the distance. What happened to Alex is uncertain, but Masky appears chronologically in Entry #33 afterwards, meaning he survived the encounter. If he has a limp, it is most likely due to being shot in the leg. Tim appears at the very end of the tape as himself, walking about town. Jay states he's going to follow Tim and see what's going on, but doesn't know when he'll update next.
Tim's thirteenth appearance.
Entry #53 has Jay note that the building he saw Tim leave at the end of #52 months ago was an antique shop, however Jay notes via camera that the store is closed, with a sign in the yard. Several weeks passed until a person who worked at the store showed up so Jay could question her. He speaks with an older woman, asking her if she's seen anyone of Tim's description. She does recognize a young man of that appearance, noting he always seems to stop by on his way to his doctor's appointment which may be a building down the street. Jay thanks the woman and the camera cuts out. When it comes back, Jay notes that when he did find this "doctor's office" that it was a mentall health clinic. Knowing privacy act would not permit any professional inside the establishment to disclose any information regarding Tim to Jay, Jay decides his best bet is to sit outside and wait for Tim to show. Tim eventually shows up, coughing as he usually does. Jay catches his attention and uses his lie from Entry #13, that he's continuing Alex's movie, but Tim seems concerned and confused, and heads inside for his doctor's appointment after a very short conversation. Although Jay waited outside, he tells Tim when he leaves that he happened to be walking by to see if Tim had left yet. Tim lights up a cigarette (this entry indicating Tim may be coughing due to cigarettes) and the two talk while walking down the street. Jay tries to lead him with "are you OK" questions to make Tim tell him why he was in the clinic, but Tim just answers he is okay and doesn't actually tell him. Tim gets a call and coughs, then asks Jay for his phone number and says it was work and he has to leave. Tim walks away while smoking and coughing. Jay notes afterwards that he didn't appear to remember anything regarding Jay. While wandering the city, Jay gets a call from Tim, who states he may have some of Alex's old behind-the-scene tapes. Tim offers to hand em over, and Jay accepts.
Entry #54 starts with Jay going to meet Tim over the tapes. Tim hands the tapes over, then asks Jay why he
Tim's Fourteenth Appearance.
constantly films everything with his camera. Jay states it's a behind-the-scenes thing. Tim accepts that answer. Jay tries to ask what's on the tapes, but Tim doesn't actually know, as they were shot on one of Alex's cameras, but when he gave the camera back, he forgot to give back the tapes, and lacks any such device to be capable of playing said tapes, thus he doesn't, as a result, know their contents. Tim departs back to work, and Jay takes his new cache. The first tape Jay watches shows what appears to be him, someone who appears to be Seth, and Tim all talking, as they run to someone's house during a rainstorm, but get soaked. Alex appears to be on his way. Seth departs shortly. Jay departs afterwards, and Tim heads into his apartment. The video jump cuts to Alex (behind the camera) and Tim inside said apartment. Alex appears to be sarcastically looking at his items in the apartment (which are mostly musical equipment), and eventually Brian shows up. The three appear to debate over what music to use in the trailer. The power goes out (possibly due to the storm), and Tim sets out to get the power back on leaving Alex and Brian. Eventually the power returns, and Tim, after stumbling about in the dark and hurting himself, turns back to what appears to be a bedroom or living room where The Operator is standing in the corner, however Tim makes no note of him at all, suggesting that he may be invisible. After this note, the power cuts out once more. While in the dark trying to find the breaker box, static assaults the audio suggesting that The Operator is following him through the apartment. Unable to turn the power back on, he grabs a flashlight, and now The Operator appears to be gone from the bed/living room. The three appear to be in the dark afterwards and use the flashlight to try and set up music, however a shadow shoots across the wall and the video cuts out. Jay notes the tape ends there.
Tim's behavior is very erratic. Entry #23, 45, 50, and 52 show Masky not attacking Jay and instead leading him around or helping him, whereas his other appearances have him typically attacking Jay. Both Masky and Hoody appear to work together, and want Alex dead for an unknown reason. It is for this reason many people are unsure of his connections with The Operator. It is never strictly stated that Masky works alongside or with the Operator, but viewers have connected him to the Operator and have speculated and accepted that his position is that of a lacky or cultist (hence, a proxy) to the Operator. The two are never seen together, and some speculate that he and Hoody were scared away from murdering Alex by the Operator in Entry #45. Some back this claim up by claiming that Alex and the Operator are not truly foes by that time, as they believe that Alex's reaction to the Operator in Entry #46 suggest that Alex and the Operator are friendly towards each other. These same theorists say that Masky may be trying to help Jay by killing Alex, because they know that he works for The Operator. Since Masky's behavior is erratic at best, he may actually want to stop The Operator and aid Jay as much as there is a possibility he is also hostile or completely neutral, leading everyone else around. Most of the series has left Tim with a mysterious cough, however Entry #52, 53, and 54 indicate that it may be due to excessive smoking.
Entry #55 Starts with Alex, Brian, and Tim walk down the street discussing a potential location for Brian's "Abandoned School" for the movie. Alex notes he hasn't found anything, but Tim has found a burned out hopsital that he honestly believes it could pass for a school. It's very far away, however, but Alex seems cool with it. The two decide to do it on a saturdy, meaning that Entry #51 takes place near the end of the week. The group then proceed to get shots, before Tim gets a call by his doctor confirming his appointment, and Tim notes he has been having headaches, paranoia, and insomnia for years now, and has been sleeping even worse than normal to the person on the phone. The shooting then commences on.
In Entry #56 you can hear Tim (who is holding the camera) talking to Alex (who is offscreen) talking about the hospital mentioned from the previous entry. Alex mentions that things came up and he forgot about it for a while, and that Tim and himself are there just to scout the location until Brian and Seth show. Tim appears okay with this. At one point Alex notices a building nearby. Tim tries to persuade him that this building they are in is better, but Alex desires to see it. They first head upstairs, and Tim puts down his camera to pee. Alex also puts down his camera, and grabs a piece of fallen rebar. He hits Tim offscreen, who stops talking after the blow. The camera flips for no discernible reason, and show The Operator standing in the room on the other side for several moments before he vanishes. Alex then walks into view of the camera and drops the rebar before walking offscreen again. The last thing heard is Tim coughing.
Tim's seventeenth appearance.
In Entry #57, Tim awakens at night with the camera (while having a coughing fit). He turns on the night vision and attempts to find a way out of the abandoned building. He eventually does make it outside the building, but is unable to find an escape route due to the dense foliage, darkness, and potential lack of method to return home. He heads back the building (most likely for safety reasons until dawn) upon which he notes Alex; whom is carrying a large pipe and flashlight. Alex's presence here is unknown for what purpose, but he does appear to be hunting something. Tim manages to give him the slip and hides in a small annex, but is unable to stop himself from progressively coughing harder and harder. The camera distorts and the video ends.
Entry #58 has Tim showing Jay the building they were going to shoot in. Jay sees the hospital, but tells Tim he
Tim's twenty-first appearance.
is more interested in a second building on the premises. Unable to sway Jay, Tim takes Jay to the second building, and the two search the building. Tim is on edge the entire time. While searching, Jay hears a wooden plank fall, and demands an investigation. Tim reassures him its the building falling apart with age, but Jay investigates regardless (much to Tim's Chagrin). While exploring, Jay takes off running, and Tim chases after. Tim finally catches Jay, and demands why he's doing this, but Jay continues on with his story about just wanting to finish the movie. Tim demands they return to their cars. Tim, now frustrated, tells Jay he is done helping him with whatever he was working on, and the two part ways when the entry ends.
Tim's Twenty-second appearance.
Entry #59 starts with Jay in his car. Tim does show up shortly, after Jay's aside, in normal attire, and Jay tries to speak, however Tim promptly punches Jay hard, knocking the camera to the ground where it lays for the entire entry. Tim then yells "SHOOTING A FILM YOU LYING PIECE OF...!", showing that he has come to the conclusion that Jay is lying. Tim, yelling, then admits that after the hospital incident he researched Marble Hornets and found the youtube video Entries. Tim is angry that it took Jay until now to admit what was going on rather than when they were running about possibly getting themselves into danger. He also clearly becomes distressed knowing that the entries showed Jay waiting outside the doctor's office just for Tim for an extended period. Jay admits the secrecy was due to being unable to trust Tim, and states that if Tim did indeed see the entries then Tim understands why, phrasing "Can you blame me?". Tim retors with having a lot of things he can "Blame [Jay] for right now". Jay pleads with Tim, citing that he knew he couldn't just walk up to Tim and ask questions regarding everything. Tim ignores the question and states that now things make sense. So many years of torment have finally been unpuzzled. Tim then goes on a monolugue stating that he was finally getting better, that for periods he would wake up in unknown locations in blood, or be unable to hold a job due to being absent for weeks without realizing more than a day had passed. He tells Jay to imagine waking up with your life broken "and no memory whatsoever of that happening." He was finally getting better, however Jay showing up has returned some of the bad effects in slight and thus has caused Tim stress. He accuses Jay of being selfish as his actions affect everyone else. He also yells at Jay due to the fact that pointing his camera at the problem isn't the same as solving it. Jay states so people will know his last testament basically, however Tim retorts with the fact that it is a bunch of online videos and nobody cares. He also cites Jay being insane, as Alex had pointed a gun at him and yet Jay filmed the entire ordeal instead of being proactive. Jay gets angry and reminds Tim of the Masky psychopath situation, and Tim yells at Jay to "shut up!" and that he is NOT a psychopath. He then states that is all Alex's fault to begin with admittedly. He explains the reason he's truly @#!*% with Jay is not so much causing the problems again, but that Jay has known about these issues for years and has never once tried to explain the situationn to Tim. Jay, however, retorts with that fact that he had no idea that if he indeed did come clean, that such an option would be safe and he wouldn't be killed. He came to Tim because he needed help, and states that Jessica is missing. Tim, not apparently knowing Jessica, states that Jessica was a girl he has spoken to a grand total of "two times" (as Tim says) and that Jay has no proof beyond Alex's crazed behavior that he is in any way involved in Jessia's appearance. Tim then scolds Jay, stating that Jessica was perfectly well off until Jay began muddling in her life with the The Operator situation and Amy. He then states that perhaps the reason all this is happening isn't Alex, but rather Jay, and that by involving himself with people he has only served to make the issue worse. Jay tries to state that Jessica isn't the only missing person (Amy, Seth, Sarah, etc.), however Tim states that he won't help. Jay, distressed, demands to know what it is that Tim wants from him. Tim then states that Jay can keep making his videos and being chased while "not being very good" at fixing the situation, but he wants Jay to never bother him again. Jay, at this point, picks up the camera and walks towards Tim, trying to plead one last time, however Tim turns and yells at Jay that he can keep uploading his "detective videos", but he demands Jay never interfere with his life again. At this, Tim angrily enters his car and drives away.
With the inclusion of evidence from Entry #59, it can be concluded that the Masky personality shifts are actually completely involunatry, that Tim does not actually remember any of such events, and that he has been unknowing of The Operator up until this point. He was an innocent bystander caught in the crossfire of Alex. How the Masky shifts come about is not yet stated, but it is certain that, if Tim is not lying, the Masky persona is not under his control.
Tim's Twenty-third appearance.
In Entry #61, Hoody breaks into Tim's house, videotaping the entire event. Hoody videos himself taking Tim's pill bottle and then sets the camera at a vantage point before hiding in the closet. Tim re-enters the room coughing heavily, causing audio distortion. He attempts to find his pills but is unable to take them because Hoody stole them. Tim appears to have a seizure, causing heavy audio and visual distortion. Eventually Tim is shown crying in the corner, causing more audio distortion. The camera cuts out a few times during this sequence, causing distorted images to appear. Tim then staggers to his feet and leaves the room, unaware of the camera or Hoody hiding in his closet.
Tim's Twenty-fourth appearance.
In Entry #62, Jay wanders into an area of Rosswood Park where he believes Tim ran off to. However, he encounters Masky, who chases him before eventually capturing him and dragging him off camera. Hoody then appears and turns off the camera, although due to Hoody's actions in the previous entry it's unclear whether Masky and Hoody are working together or Hoody is working alone. When Jay wakes up, he finds himself in a dilapidated old cabin in a previously unseen area of Rosswood. Outside he finds Tim, who is still dressed in Masky's clothes, but no longer has the mask on. Tim seems to be waking up after falling unconscious. He has no memory at all of his time as Masky, nor does he have any idea how he and Jay wound up near the cabin.
Tim's Twenty-fifth appearance.
In Entry #63, Tim and Jay are discussing and arguing on what to do. It is revealed that Tim(not Masky but actually Tim) hates Hoody(the person who stole the medical records to tim) and wants to get rid of Hoody before helping Jay find Jessica.